Elliptical vs. Treadmill: Which Is Best for Weight Loss?

We may receive compensation from the providers of the services and products featured on this website. Read our Advertising Disclosure.

If you’ve ever embarked on a diet, you might remember the realization that dieting alone isn’t the magic solution to shedding pounds. It takes more than just cutting calories—it’s about movement too. Picture yourself in the crisp morning air, lacing up your sneakers for a brisk walk or jog, or perhaps stepping onto a machine that hums with promise. Running and walking have long been trusted companions in the quest for health, burning calories while strengthening your heart. These classic exercises can be enjoyed outdoors, where the world feels wide and open, or indoors on an elliptical machine or treadmill, each offering its own rhythm and pace.

But here’s a question that might take you back to those moments of decision in the gym: elliptical or treadmill? Both have their merits, but which is the better partner for your weight loss journey? Let’s take a step back and explore these machines, comparing their features and benefits to help you find the one that fits your needs and preferences best. After all, the right choice is the one that keeps you moving forward, both figuratively and literally.

An Overview of the Elliptical Machine

Array of Amazon Ellipticals

Elliptical machines first glided into the fitness scene in the mid-1990s, thanks to Precor, and quickly became a beloved staple for minimal-impact cardio. If you were around back then, you might remember the early models—sturdy machines with fixed handles, helping you balance as you worked up a sweat focusing solely on your lower body. Over time, those stationary handles evolved into moving ones, offering a full-body workout that felt almost futuristic.

Today, elliptical machines come in three main types, each with its own quirks and charm:

• Front drive: Imagine the feel of a classic stair machine—leaning forward slightly as you push through each step. That’s the essence of a front-drive elliptical. With the flywheel positioned at the front, these are often the go-to choice for home gyms. They’re simple, affordable, and bring just the basics—perfect for a straightforward workout.
• Rear drive: If you’ve ever set foot in a gym, chances are you’ve tried a rear-drive elliptical. These models place the flywheel at the back, creating a smooth and balanced ride. They’re larger and bulkier than front-drive machines, but there’s something satisfyingly sturdy about their design, making them a staple in fitness centers everywhere.
• Center drive: The new kid on the block, center-drive ellipticals, take a modern twist. With the flywheel nestled at the center and pedals on either side, these machines help you stand straighter, offering a more natural posture. It’s a sleek, innovative option for those who want a fresh take on the elliptical experience.

Whether you remember the early days of ellipticals or are discovering them for the first time, these machines offer a timeless way to move your body and get your heart pumping. Each type has its own story, inviting you to step on and be part of the journey.

Read Elliptical Machine Reviews

Muscles Worked on an Elliptical Machine

Shutterstock

Elliptical machines—do you remember the first time you stepped onto one? Maybe it was at a neighborhood gym or during a fitness craze of years past. These trusty machines have remained a staple for a reason: they deliver a full-body workout while evoking the simplicity of brisk walks or long-forgotten dance moves.

Let’s start with the lower body, where the elliptical shines brightest. As you glide back and forth, you’re engaging key muscles that power movement. Think of your calves (the gastrocnemius), propelling you forward, or your glutes (yes, the ever-important gluteus maximus), adding strength to every stride. The hamstrings and quadriceps, those familiar workhorses of the thighs, work in perfect harmony, while your tibialis anterior—the unsung hero of the shins—helps stabilize each motion. It’s a symphony of movement that brings to mind the act of running across a field or climbing a hill, without the wear and tear on your joints.

But don’t let the lower body steal all the glory. The elliptical quietly tones the upper body as well, though perhaps with a more subtle touch. Grasp those handles, and you’ll feel your biceps (front of the arms) and triceps (upper arms) come alive, as if recalling the effort of lifting something heavy in a moment of need. Your core engages to keep you balanced, while your chest muscles (pectoralis major) help drive the motion forward. It’s a reminder that even small movements can have a powerful impact, much like the rhythmic sway of a rowing boat or the smooth pull of a typewriter’s carriage return.

Whether you’re reliving past fitness routines or exploring the elliptical for the first time, it offers a workout that connects the past to the present, blending nostalgia with strength and endurance. Ready to step on and glide into motion?

Elliptical Machine Pros

Amazon

Elliptical machines—remember when they first started appearing in gyms? It was like a small revolution in cardio workouts, offering something fresh, smooth, and easier on the joints. These machines have become a staple for a reason, and here’s why:

• A full-body workout for the multitasker: Think back to those cross-training days of yore—ellipticals bring that to life. While your legs glide in a steady rhythm, the moveable handles let your arms join the action too. It’s like the modern-day equivalent of rowing and running combined, all without ever leaving your spot.
• Effortless calorie burn: The beauty of an elliptical lies in how deceptively easy it feels. You step on, start moving, and before you know it, you’re sweating buckets. It’s a workout that sneaks up on you, burning more calories than you’d expect—like a workout secret weapon.
• Low-impact for those tender joints: For anyone who’s nursed a sore knee or rolled an ankle, ellipticals are a gift. They let you mimic the rhythmic stride of walking or running without the harsh pounding that comes from hitting a treadmill or the pavement. It’s the perfect throwback to when workouts weren’t about pain, but about movement that feels good.
• Reverse your stride, reverse your day: Ever try going backward on an elliptical? It’s a bit of a throwback to childhood adventures—remember running or biking backward just for the fun of it? Here, it’s functional. Reversing your stride activates muscles you don’t even realize you’re skipping, adding a playful twist to your workout.

The Elliptical: A Few Bumps on the Road

Of course, even the most beloved fitness inventions have their quirks. Ellipticals, for all their charm, have a few drawbacks to consider:

• Less dynamic than a treadmill: Think of treadmills as the thrill-seekers of the cardio world. You can crank up the incline, speed up the pace, and mimic steep hill climbs. Ellipticals, while steady and reliable, don’t always offer the same challenge. Some models try, but not all can replicate that dynamic variability.
• Not quite the real thing: For purist runners who love the feel of their sneakers hitting the pavement or the steady hum of a treadmill belt, ellipticals can feel… well, a bit artificial. It’s like comparing a classic vinyl record to a modern playlist—effective, but it doesn’t quite have the same soul.
• The case of numb feet: Here’s a small quirk you might not expect—some folks notice their feet feeling numb during longer sessions. It’s because your feet stay planted on the pedals, reducing circulation. A small price to pay for the low-impact magic, but worth noting if it’s a recurring issue.

Ellipticals might not be perfect, but they’ve earned their place in fitness lore—a modern invention that’s here to stay, offering an accessible, joint-friendly way to keep moving. Whether you’re rekindling an old love for cardio or trying one for the first time, there’s something timeless about their smooth, steady rhythm.

Read Elliptical Machine Reviews

Benefits of an Elliptical Machine

Elliptical machines bring a wealth of benefits, reminding us how far fitness technology has come since the old days of clunky gym equipment. Remember those? These modern marvels offer so much more, blending functionality with ease.

• A full-body workout: Imagine the rhythmic motion, your arms and legs moving in perfect harmony, working together like a well-tuned orchestra. Ellipticals engage both upper and lower body muscles, giving you that balanced burn.
• Low-impact exercise: Unlike pounding the pavement in old-school running shoes, ellipticals let your feet glide effortlessly on smooth pedals—perfect for anyone nursing an injury or just avoiding joint strain.
• Weight-bearing benefits: Back in the day, people relied on walking and manual labor to strengthen their bones. Today, ellipticals provide a weight-bearing exercise that helps combat osteoporosis, all while keeping things easy on the joints.

Thinking about adding one of these wonders to your home gym? Step into the future (with a nod to the past) and check out the best elliptical machines. Your fitness routine will thank you!

Who Is the Elliptical Machine Suited for?

Pixabay

Have you ever wandered into a gym, glanced at the cardio machines, and felt a flicker of déjà vu? Maybe it reminded you of a time when treadmills had those clunky red emergency cords or when elliptical machines were the shiny newcomers on the block. The age-old question—elliptical vs. treadmill—might have crossed your mind. Which one is better? Well, that depends on what you’re looking for.

Ellipticals bring to mind the ease of movement, almost like gliding across ice or pedaling a bike in slow motion. They’re a lifeline for anyone seeking a low-impact workout. Maybe you’re just starting your fitness journey, testing the waters like dipping a toe into a chilly lake. Or perhaps your knees whisper reminders of years spent running marathons, dancing at concerts, or simply living life to the fullest. The elliptical offers a gentle reprieve, a way to stay active without pushing past the limits of comfort or recovery.

It’s a choice that feels like self-care—an acknowledgment of what your body has been through and how it can still move forward.An

Overview of the Treadmill

Array of Amazon images

Treadmills have a fascinating history, stretching back centuries to the days of the Roman Empire. Picture this: around the late first century, massive “treadmill cranes” or “tread wheels” were crafted to help lift heavy loads, their wooden mechanisms powered by human or animal effort. Fast forward to the 1950s, and the treadmill found a new purpose in medicine, aiding doctors in diagnosing heart and lung conditions. By the 1960s, these once-utilitarian machines transformed yet again, becoming sleek in-home exercise companions, bringing the gym into countless living rooms.

Today, treadmills are cherished for their ability to mimic the natural rhythm of walking and running. They offer a reliable path to a heart-pumping cardio session or a calorie-burning routine, whether you’re chasing fitness goals or simply enjoying the steady, comforting pace of a journey without leaving home. It’s remarkable to think how something with such ancient roots has evolved to become a modern-day staple of health and wellness.

Read Treadmill Reviews

Muscles Worked on a Treadmill

Shutterstock

Elliptical machines and treadmills—both icons of the modern gym, each with its unique charm. Remember those early days of fitness trends, when treadmills lined up in neat rows, calling out to runners and walkers alike? And then, the elliptical arrived, a sleek new addition that promised a full-body workout. These machines have shaped countless workouts, and understanding their differences can help you decide where to step next—literally.

Ellipticals are like a throwback to cross-country skiing, engaging both your upper and lower body while giving your cardiovascular system a hearty workout. Treadmills, on the other hand, take you back to the simplicity of running or walking—just you and the moving belt beneath your feet. They target your lower body and core with precision and help strengthen the very muscles that power your stride:

• Core muscles (abs): the foundation of stability
• Gastrocnemius (calves): those hard-working muscles that give your step a spring
• Gluteus maximus (buttocks): the powerhouse behind your stride
• Hamstrings (back of thighs): keeping every movement smooth and controlled
• Quadriceps (front of thighs): propelling you forward with energy
• Tibialis anterior (lower shins): aiding in every lift and step

And if you’re like those early morning joggers, pumping your arms with determination, you’ll even give your upper body a light workout, stirring memories of fitness routines past. Your biceps and pectorals—the muscles that flex and push—get in on the action, though not as much as they would on an elliptical.

So, whether it’s the elliptical’s full-body flow or the treadmill’s focused grind, these machines have become trusted companions on countless fitness journeys, each step and stride a testament to their timeless appeal. Which one will you choose to power your workout story?

Treadmill Pros

Shutterstock

Once upon a time, treadmills and ellipticals didn’t exist—running meant braving the open road or circling a dusty track. But today, these machines bring the workout indoors, each offering its own unique benefits. Let’s take a closer look, shall we?

The elliptical has its charm, offering a smooth, low-impact glide that feels like skating on air. But the treadmill? Ah, it gives you options. Whether you’re walking leisurely like a 1950s suburbanite strolling the neighborhood, or sprinting with the determination of an Olympic runner, the treadmill is a versatile companion.

Treadmill Pros

Let’s start with the highlights. Treadmills have a way of making exercise straightforward and familiar—like slipping into a pair of well-worn sneakers.

• Easy to use: From beginners finding their stride to seasoned athletes chasing a PR, treadmills are simple. Just press a button, and off you go, like stepping onto a moving sidewalk at the airport.
• Incline magic: Remember the satisfaction of climbing a hill on a cool autumn afternoon? Treadmills capture that feeling with better incline options than most ellipticals.
• Runner’s delight: For those who crave the rhythmic pounding of feet on a path, only a treadmill can mimic the experience of a run. The elliptical may be perfect for a cross-training day, but it won’t replace the joy of running.
• Workout variety: Want a gentle walk to clear your head or an intense sprint to relive your track team days? A treadmill offers both, shifting effortlessly from low to high impact depending on your pace.

Treadmill Cons

Like a beautifully restored vintage car, treadmills come with their own quirks—charming or challenging, depending on how you see them. Let’s take a stroll through a few of their drawbacks.

• The cost of convenience: Investing in a treadmill can feel a bit like buying a ticket to the future. Compared to a free jog around the neighborhood, its price might seem steep. Yet, much like a reliable old jukebox or a well-worn record player, some might argue that the convenience is worth every penny.
• No downhill thrills: Remember the rush of racing downhill as a kid, arms outstretched, wind whipping past your face? Treadmills can’t quite replicate that carefree feeling. Gravity’s playful tug doesn’t make it indoors, leaving the downhill joy as a memory of open roads and sunlit trails.
• Safety concerns: With their steady, whirring belts, treadmills demand your focus, much like threading a needle or balancing on a wide wooden swing. A single misstep could lead to a stumble—a moment reminiscent of falling off the monkey bars, a mix of fleeting panic and bruised pride.

In the end, the treadmill is a modern marvel, a nod to the timeless joy of running and walking, reimagined for indoor living. It might not capture every nuance of the great outdoors, but for many, it’s a bridge between the past and present—a way to embrace the spirit of movement without ever stepping out the door.

Benefits of a Treadmill

If you enjoy the simple pleasures of walking or running but prefer the comfort of staying indoors, treadmills might just become your new favorite companion. They’re like a modern twist on the walking paths and running trails that have been part of our lives for generations. Let’s take a stroll through some of their benefits:

• Cardiovascular health: Think of the treadmill as your partner in heart health. With each step, you’re strengthening your heart, much like the long walks people once took to the local market or through their neighborhoods.
• Joint health: Walking on a treadmill offers a gentler way to stay active—a low-impact exercise that’s easy on your joints, reminiscent of those slow, deliberate walks through a garden on a sunny day. Just remember, while walking is kind to your joints, running can be a little more demanding.
• Mental health: Ever heard of the elusive “runner’s high”? A treadmill can help you chase that feeling—a euphoria not unlike the satisfaction of a job well done or the joy of a crisp morning stroll.
• Weight loss: Treadmills have a knack for helping you meet your weight loss goals, much like how steady, purposeful effort has always brought about meaningful change.

So, whether you’re imagining yourself on the paths of yesteryears or simply relishing the rhythmic hum of a treadmill in your home, this piece of equipment is ready to be part of your journey.

Who Is the Treadmill For?

Shutterstock

Treadmills bring to mind the rhythms of indoor exercise—a throwback to simpler days when staying active meant lacing up your sneakers and stepping onto a familiar machine, rain or shine. For those who love the feel of walking or running but prefer the comfort of home, treadmills are a timeless solution. They’re perfect companions for improving cardiovascular health, easing into a new fitness routine, or alternating between low-impact strolls and high-energy sprints. Imagine marathon training during a blustery winter, your strides steady and unwavering, safely indoors while the world outside rages with cold or rain.

If you’re dreaming of adding this classic piece of equipment to your home gym, take a look at the best treadmills. They might just bring a spark of nostalgia and a fresh start to your fitness journey.

Elliptical Machine vs. Treadmill

Shutterstock

Ah, treadmills and ellipticals—two staples of the modern gym. Yet, as you debate which is best for weight loss, let’s take a step back and remember how these machines became part of our fitness routines in the first place. Decades ago, the treadmill was a symbol of endurance, a tool for runners training through rain and snow when the roads weren’t an option. The elliptical, a younger invention, entered the scene with its smooth, low-impact glides, offering a gentler path to fitness. Both have their origins in the quest for better health, and both have their place.

So, which one should you choose? The truth is, it depends entirely on you. Both machines have the potential to help you shed pounds, tone your body, and keep your heart strong, but the results hinge on how you use them. Picture this: a runner pounding out five miles a day on a treadmill, sweat dripping, muscles burning—compare that to a casual 30-minute stroll on an elliptical. The difference in weight loss is clear.

And if we’re talking numbers, treadmills often edge out the competition. A 180-pound person doing a 45-minute workout would burn around 675 calories on a treadmill, compared to 441 calories on an elliptical. That’s a significant gap, but it doesn’t make one machine better than the other—it just means they serve different purposes.

Now that you know the story behind these two fitness giants and the role they can play in your journey, the choice is yours. Whether it’s the steady rhythm of the treadmill or the smooth glide of the elliptical, find the one that fits your routine and your goals. After all, the best machine is the one that keeps you moving.